Exploring Eleuthera: A Perfect Week in Paradise

Why Visit Eleuthera?

Eleuthera, a 110-mile-long island in the Bahamas, is known for its pink sand beaches, crystal-clear waters, and laid-back atmosphere. Rich in history, Eleuthera was first settled in the 1600s by the Eleutheran Adventurers, a group of English Puritans seeking religious freedom. The island’s name, derived from the Greek word for “freedom,” perfectly reflects its tranquil and unspoiled beauty. With world-class snorkeling, fishing, and stunning natural attractions, Eleuthera offers the perfect balance of adventure and relaxation for every traveler.

Aerial view flying into Eleuthera

Aerial view flying into Eleuthera

2 brothers posing on the beach while enjoying a Bahamian beer after arriving in Eleuthera.

View from an AirBnb in Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera Looking out from the back patio.

Preparing to go Lobster Spearing with Captain Kid Tours

Part of our catch Lobster spearing

Pleased with our successful day Lobster Spearing in Eleuthera, Bahamas.

A look at our successful catch Reef Fishing in Eleuthera, Bahamas.

Pig Island at the north end of Eleuthera is a great place to stop and see the swimming pigs.

There are over 20 pigs there who were excited to see us.

Visiting the ocean swings off the north end of Eleuthera was one of the trip highlights.

As we arrived, 4 stingrays swam over to greet us.

The friendly stingrays rubbed against us as we fed and pet them.

The ocean swings in Eleuthera are a lot of fun with beautiful views of clear blue Bahamian water.

The water there is less than a foot deep certain times of day at the sandbar.

The sandbar is a great place to spend an afternoon

Other than the stingrays, there was no one else within miles.

Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera, has great snorkeling right off the shore!

Hidden beach on the Atlantic Ocean side near Rainbow Bay only visible at low tide.

Kayaking up to Rainbow Bay Beach through crystal clear water.

Beautiful secluded beach in Eleuthera, Bahamas.

Overlooking the Atlantic Ocean near Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera.

Sunrise over the Atlantic Ocean at a secluded beach near Rainbow Bay, Eleuthera.

Sunset over the Caribbean from our AirBnb in Eleuthera, Bahamas.

Getting There: Flights to Eleuthera

Eleuthera is accessible via two main airports: North Eleuthera International Airport (ELH) and Governor’s Harbour International Airport (GHB). North Eleuthera offers more flight options from the U.S. with major airlines such as American Airlines, Delta, and United providing service from hubs like Miami, Charlotte, Fort Lauderdale, and Atlanta. If you’re staying further south on the island, flying into Governor’s Harbour may be more convenient, as it reduces drive time to your accommodation. Both airports have rental car services and taxis available, making it easy to get to your destination.

Accommodations: Great Places to Stay in Eleuthera

While our itinerary is based on a stay at The Cove, one of our favorite resorts, there are several other fantastic accommodation options on the island which we also recommend:

French Leave Resort (Governor’s Harbour)

Located in Governor’s Harbour, French Leave Resort is an upscale beachfront property offering luxurious villas with stunning ocean views. Part of the Marriott Autograph Collection, the resort features a private pink sand beach, an infinity pool, and a top- rated restaurant serving fresh Bahamian cuisine. The location in Governor’s Harbour provides easy access to local shops, restaurants, and attractions like Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve and Twin Cove Beach.

Potlatch Club

For a more intimate and exclusive experience, Potlatch Club offers a unique boutique- style stay. This historic property, set on a pristine stretch of pink sand beach, blends modern comforts with Bahamian charm. Guests can enjoy beachfront cottages, a private setting, and close proximity to Governor’s Harbour’s vibrant dining scene. It’s an ideal choice for those looking for a peaceful, upscale retreat.

Vacation Rentals in Rainbow Bay

A vacation rental is a great way to enjoy more space, privacy, and flexibility during your stay on Eleuthera. It’s an especially good option for families or groups, allowing you to cook your own meals—perfect if you plan on fishing or picking up fresh seafood from a local market.

We recommend Rainbow Bay as a top location for vacation rentals for several reasons:

• Stunning Natural Beauty – The area boasts beautiful beaches, excellent snorkeling spots, and breathtaking sunset views.

• Central Location – Rainbow Bay is conveniently located between North Eleuthera Airport and Governor’s Harbour, making it easy to explore both ends of the island.

• Proximity to Attractions – Staying here allows for easy day trips north to Spanish Wells and Harbour Island, while also being just a short drive south to Governor’s Harbour’s restaurants and nightlife.

• Waterfront Access – Many rentals in Rainbow Bay are right on the water, providing direct access for swimming, kayaking, and paddleboarding right from your backyard.

  
  

No matter where you choose to stay, Eleuthera offers incredible experiences, stunning scenery, and warm Bahamian hospitality that will make your trip unforgettable!

7 Night Stay - Sample Itinerary

Day 1: Arrival and Relaxation at The Cove

Check into The Cove Eleuthera, a luxury beachfront resort offering stunning ocean views, infinity pools, and a peaceful ambiance. Spend your afternoon exploring the resort, lounging by the pool or private beach, and unwinding from your travels. For dinner, enjoy fresh seafood and gourmet cuisine at The Cove’s restaurant, known for its exceptional dishes and romantic oceanfront setting.

Day 2: Fishing Charter & Dinner at Daddy Joe’s

Book a fishing charter for a half-day or full-day adventure. Eleuthera offers some of the best fishing in the world, from reef fishing to deep-sea sport fishing. Some top-rated charter companies include:

• Spanish Wells Fishing (Spanish Wells)

• Lil B Fishing (Harbour Island)

• Eleuthera Fishing Charters (North Eleuthera)

After a successful day on the water, stop at Daddy Joe’s, a beloved local restaurant serving Bahamian cuisine, including fresh seafood, burgers, and tropical cocktails in a relaxed setting.

Day 3: Snorkeling & Dinner at Tippy’s

Eleuthera boasts incredible snorkeling spots accessible from shore. Some of the best include:

• Gaulding Cay – Calm waters and vibrant marine life.

• Twin Coves – Shallow reefs teeming with tropical fish.

• Lighthouse Beach – A remote and breathtaking snorkeling experience.

In the evening, head to Tippy’s in Governor’s Harbour for a beachfront dining experience with live music and a fantastic menu featuring fresh seafood and Caribbean flavors.

Day 4: Exploring Harbour Island by Golf Cart

Take the ferry to Harbour Island, famous for its pink sand beaches and charming colonial-style streets. Rent a golf cart and explore key spots like:

• Pink Sands Beach – A must-visit.

• Dunmore Town – Quaint shops and historic architecture.

• The Landing – A great lunch spot with fresh, local ingredients.

For dinner, try Rock House or The Dunmore, both offering upscale island dining with stunning ocean views.

Day 5: Boat Rental & Sandbar Adventures

Rent a boat from Harborside Rentals or book a private charter with a captain to explore Eleuthera’s hidden gems, including:

• Ocean Swings – A shallow sandbar where friendly stingrays swim up to visitors.

• Pig Island – A chance to swim with the famous Bahamian pigs.

• Shipwreck Snorkeling – A fascinating underwater site teeming with marine life.

• Reef Snorkeling – there are great reefs around the area that offer fantastic snorkeling.

• Lobster spearing – The area offers the best lobster spearing in the Bahamas.  Rent lobster spears from Harborside Rentals and give it a try!

Stop at The Sandbar Beach Bar & Grill on Russell Island for a laid-back lunch with beautiful beach views.

Day 6: Land Exploration & Hidden Gems

Spend the day exploring Eleuthera’s natural wonders:

• Preacher’s Cave – A historical site where the island’s first settlers took refuge.

• The Sapphire Blue Hole – A stunning natural swimming hole (bring a flashlight!).

• Glass Window Bridge – A famous natural rock formation showcasing the deep blue Atlantic Ocean on one side and the calm turquoise Caribbean Sea on the other.

For lunch, pick a random roadside eatery to experience authentic Bahamian flavors. Spend the afternoon relaxing at The Cove and enjoy dinner at the resort’s restaurant.

Day 7: Relaxation & Farewell Dinner

For your last full day, slow down and enjoy The Cove’s amenities. Lounge on the beach, swim in the infinity pool, or book a spa treatment. In the afternoon, visit Governor’s Harbour to explore local shops and grab a drink at The Buccaneer Club before heading to The Potlatch Club for an unforgettable farewell dinner.

Day 8: Departure

Both airports in Eleuthera are small, and flights tend to operate within a short time window, making them crowded during peak departure times. Arrive at least 2 hours before your flight to ensure a smooth check-in process.

Additional Tips for Visiting Eleuthera

• Cash is essential – Many small businesses and restaurants operate on a cash-only basis.

• Renting a car is recommended – The island is long and spread out, making a rental car the best way to explore.

• Bring snorkeling gear – While some hotels provide equipment, having your own ensures you’re ready for spontaneous underwater adventures.

• Bring an underwater camera – if you don’t have one, you can buy an inexpensive waterproof phone sleeve from Amazon.

• Book reservations early – Popular restaurants and excursions fill up fast, so plan ahead.

• Trip insurance is highly recommended – Weather and travel delays can impact plans,

With its unspoiled beauty, warm hospitality, and endless adventure opportunities, Eleuthera is a true tropical paradise waiting to be explored! Contact us to start planning an unforgettable trip to Eleuthera!

Contact Us